Fibre, Cable, DSL or 5G: Which Connection Is Right for You?
Fibre, cable, DSL and 5G home internet compared on speed, latency, upload, stability and availability. A neutral explanation without the sales talk.
When you sign up for internet in the Netherlands or elsewhere in Europe, you’re usually choosing between four technologies: fibre, cable (coax), DSL over the phone line and, increasingly, mobile home internet via 4G or 5G. On paper the differences seem to be mostly about speed, but in practice upload speed, latency and stability matter at least as much. This article compares the technologies neutrally, so you know what to expect and what to look out for.
Fibre
With fibre, an optical fibre runs all the way into your home (Fibre to the Home, FTTH). Data travels as light, with little loss over long distances and no sensitivity to electrical interference. In the Netherlands and many other European countries, fibre has been rolled out at a rapid pace in recent years, including outside the big cities.
- Speed: plans from 100 Mbps to 1 Gbps are common; more and more networks offer 2, 4 or 8 Gbps thanks to technologies such as XGS-PON.
- Upload: often symmetrical, so as fast as the download.
- Latency: low, typically a few milliseconds to around 10 ms to nearby servers.
- Stability: excellent; distance to the exchange makes hardly any difference.
Fibre is technically the strongest option. Bear in mind that many fibre networks are shared (PON), with a number of homes sharing one fibre. In practice you rarely notice this, as the capacity is generous.
Cable (coax)
Cable internet uses the coaxial network originally built for television. With DOCSIS 3.1, high download speeds are possible. In the Netherlands, cable is available in most homes.
- Speed: up to around 1 Gbps or more download, depending on the network.
- Upload: asymmetrical. Upload is usually a fraction of download, often a few tens of Mbps.
- Latency: usually around 10 to 20 ms to nearby servers.
- Stability: good, but capacity is shared within a neighbourhood. At busy times this can be noticeable, especially if a network segment is tightly provisioned.
Cable is a perfectly good choice for most households. Its weak point is upload: for remote workers on lots of video calls, content creators and anyone sending large backups to the cloud, it can be a limitation. Its successor, DOCSIS 4.0, is designed to improve upload considerably but is only being rolled out gradually. Cable modems can also suffer from bufferbloat; more on that in what is bufferbloat.
DSL (phone line)
DSL uses the copper telephone line. Modern variants such as VDSL2 with vectoring achieve decent speeds, but only if you live close to the street cabinet. The longer the copper wire, the lower the speed.
- Speed: highly dependent on line length; roughly from a few tens of Mbps up to about 100 to 200 Mbps on short lines with the latest techniques.
- Upload: asymmetrical, usually 10 to 40 Mbps or less.
- Latency: often 10 to 30 ms; higher with interleaving (an error-correction technique).
- Stability: fair to good, but sensitive to wiring quality and interference.
In many regions DSL is a technology in decline. Network operators in several European countries are working towards phasing out copper networks as fibre becomes available. If you’re on DSL now and fibre or cable is available, switching usually brings a significant improvement.
5G and 4G home internet
Mobile home internet uses a router with a SIM card that connects to the mobile network. No cable needs to run to your home, which makes it attractive in rural areas, as a temporary solution or as a backup.
- Speed: highly variable: from a few tens to hundreds of Mbps, depending on frequency band, distance to the mast, indoor or outdoor antenna and congestion.
- Upload: asymmetrical and often significantly lower than download.
- Latency: higher than fixed connections, typically 20 to 50 ms on 5G and more on 4G.
- Stability: the least predictable. A mast’s capacity is shared with all mobile users nearby, and weather, foliage and buildings affect the signal.
Mobile home internet can work very well, but performance varies greatly by address and time of day. An outdoor antenna or a router placed by a window often makes a big difference. Also check for data caps or fair-use policies for heavy use.
Overview
| Fibre | Cable | DSL | 5G home | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Typical download | 100 Mbps–8 Gbps | 100 Mbps–1 Gbps+ | 20–200 Mbps | 50–500+ Mbps |
| Upload | Often symmetrical | Fraction of download | Low | Variable, lower |
| Latency (nearby server) | Very low | Low | Low to moderate | Moderate |
| Stability | Excellent | Good | Fair to good | Variable |
| Depends on distance | Barely | Barely | Strongly | Strongly (to the mast) |
How to choose
- Fibre available? Then it’s almost always the best technical choice, especially if you work from home, game or upload a lot.
- Cable is a strong alternative if you mainly download and stream.
- DSL is mainly an option if nothing else is available, or if you live close to the cabinet and need little.
- 5G home internet is attractive in rural areas, for temporary situations or as a backup. Check coverage at your address first.
To work out how much speed you need, read how much internet speed do I need.
Measure what you actually get
Advertised speeds are maximums. To find out what your connection really delivers, run a speed test on a laptop connected to the router with an Ethernet cable. Look beyond download to upload, ping and bufferbloat. With cable and 5G it’s wise to measure at different times, including evenings, and to use the stability test to see how consistent your connection is.
In short
- Fibre: fastest, symmetrical, lowest latency and most stable.
- Cable: high download, limited upload, shared capacity in the neighbourhood.
- DSL: strongly distance-dependent, gradually disappearing.
- 5G home: flexible, but variable in speed and latency.
- Measure wired and at different times to know what you really get.
Measure it yourself
Speed test with bufferbloat, jitter and AI explanation. Free and ad-free.